2 of the Cheapest Workers’ Comp Insurance: A Comprehensive Guide

2 of the Cheapest Workers' Comp Insurance

In the dynamic and ever-evolving business landscape, securing a reliable and affordable workers’ compensation insurance policy is not just a legal mandate but a strategic move to foster a safe and harmonious working environment.

As we delve deeper into this subject, we spotlight two industry leaders offering the most affordable solutions – Pie and Thimble.

Let us embark on this informative journey to understand the nuances of choosing 2 of the cheapest workers’ comp insurance.

Role Of Workers Comp Insurance

Workers’ compensation insurance, a cornerstone in safeguarding the interests of employees, plays a pivotal role in ensuring financial stability in the event of work-related injuries or illnesses.

In this competitive market, two providers stand tall, offering the most affordable solutions: Pie and Thimble.

This article aims to furnish you with a detailed guide on these providers, helping you make an informed decision while choosing a workers’ comp insurance policy.

Which State Has The Highest Workers Comp Rates?

Before we delve into the specifics of the providers, it is pertinent to understand the landscape of workers’ comp rates across various states.

The rates are influenced by a myriad of factors including the nature of industries predominant in a state, the historical data of work-related incidents, and the specific regulations set by individual states.

It is important to note that the geographical location of your business can significantly affect the insurance rates, given that each state has its own set of rules governing the workers’ comp insurance landscape.

Therefore, a comprehensive understanding of state-specific regulations becomes a prerequisite in selecting the most affordable insurance policy.

2 Cheapest Workers’ Comp Insurance with Guide

As we navigate the competitive market of workers’ comp insurance, Pie and Thimble emerge as the frontrunners in offering the most affordable solutions. Let us delve deeper to understand what each provider brings to the table.

Pie Insurance

Established in 2017, Pie Insurance has swiftly climbed the ranks to become a preferred choice for many businesses, primarily due to its focus on affordability without compromising on the quality of coverage.

Coverage Details
With an average monthly premium of $104 for a business harboring a workforce of 20 employees, Pie offers an annual package amounting to $1,205, striking a balance between comprehensive coverage and affordability.


  • Cost-Effectiveness: Pie stands tall as a provider offering affordable solutions, with a hassle-free quote process that takes less than a minute.
  • Flexible Plans: The provider offers plans catering to different business sizes, ensuring a cost-effective solution for all.


  • Customer Service: Despite its affordable rates, Pie has garnered a high rate of customer complaints, as noted in the NAIC complaint scores.
  • Limited Support: The absence of weekend customer support can be a downside for businesses seeking round-the-clock assistance.

Pie emerges as a viable option for small to medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) seeking cost-effective solutions. However, if customer service is a priority, exploring other avenues might be beneficial.

Thimble Insurance

Thimble, with its inception in 2016, has carved a niche in the market, standing as the second cheapest provider in the U.S, characterized by its quick quote process and competitive pricing.

Coverage Details
Offering policies with an average monthly premium of $149 and an annual cost of $1,691, Thimble ensures affordability while maintaining a strong financial stability rating from AM Best.


  • Quick Quote Process: Thimble facilitates a quick quote process, offering quotes in less than a minute, a feature that stands it apart in the competitive market.
  • Financial Stability: The provider boasts a strong financial stability rating, ensuring reliability and trustworthiness.


  • Customer Complaints: Similar to Pie, Thimble has witnessed a relatively high number of customer complaints, a factor to consider while choosing a provider.
  • Limited Customer Support: The customer support is restricted to site chat, which might not be the preferred channel for all businesses.

Thimble appears to be a suitable choice for small businesses seeking affordable solutions with a quick quote process. However, businesses preferring traditional customer service channels might want to consider other options.

Frequently Asked Questions regarding Workers’ Compensation Insurance

1. Does Workers’ Compensation Cover Business Interruption?

No, workers’ compensation does not cover business interruptions. Business interruption insurance is a separate type of policy that covers the loss of income a business suffers after an unexpected event such as a natural disaster. It is essential to note that business interruption insurance is generally included in a company’s commercial property coverage and not under workers’ compensation insurance.

2. Are Business Owners Covered by Workers’ Compensation Insurance?

Yes, business owners can opt to be covered by workers’ compensation insurance. This coverage is not automatic and must be specified in the policy. It is designed to cover the medical bills and lost wages if the business owner sustains injuries while on the job. It is a prudent choice, especially in industries prone to accidents, offering an extra layer of protection as personal health insurance might not cover medical fees for work-related injuries.

3. What is the Difference Between Workers’ Compensation and Disability Insurance?

While both workers’ compensation and disability insurance offer financial assistance in the event of an injury, they cater to different scenarios.

Workers’ compensation covers injuries sustained at the workplace or due to work-related activities.

In contrast, disability insurance covers injuries that occur outside of work and is divided into short-term and long-term disability. It is the employer’s responsibility to provide workers’ compensation insurance, which is usually mandated by law.

On the other hand, disability insurance is typically optional, with costs often shared between the employer and the employee. It is vital for businesses and employees to understand the distinct roles these insurances play to avail themselves of the appropriate benefits when needed.


As we conclude this comprehensive guide, it is evident that both Pie and Thimble offer competitive solutions in the workers’ comp insurance landscape.

While choosing a policy, it is imperative to consider state regulations and the specific needs of your business, including the employee count.

We recommend businesses to undertake a meticulous comparison of quotes and explore various payment plans to find the most cost-effective solution.


In the endeavor to foster a safe working environment, choosing the right workers’ comp insurance policy becomes a cornerstone.

Pie and Thimble, with their affordable solutions, stand as reliable allies in this journey. It is our hope that this guide aids you in making an informed decision, steering your business towards a path of safety and financial stability.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like